Valentine’s Day 2026 is approaching, and you’re probably wondering which Squishmallows will make the perfect gift for that special someone. Whether you’re shopping for a partner, friend, or treating yourself, this year’s Valentine’s collection offers something unique. From adorable strawberry cats to mythical creatures covered in hearts, we’ve narrowed down the top five options that’ll help you express your affection in the softest way possible.
| Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Olma Strawberry Cat – Official Jazwares Plush |  | Best Overall | Size: 8-Inch | Character Name: Olma | Character Type: Strawberry Cat | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Squishmallows 12in Artin Pink Loch Ness Monster |  | Most Romantic | Size: 12-Inch | Character Name: Artin | Character Type: Pink Loch Ness Monster | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Squishmallows 14in Milan Navy Blue Fruit Bat |  | Premium Pick | Size: 14-Inch | Character Name: Milan | Character Type: Navy Blue Fruit Bat | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Squishmallows 5in Herb Green Sea Turtle Plush |  | Best Mini | Size: 5-Inch | Character Name: Herb | Character Type: Green Sea Turtle | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
| Squishmallows Valentine’s Day 4-Pack (Amazon Exclusive) |  | Best Value | Size: 5-Inch (4-Pack) | Character Name: Patty, Emily, Agnolo, Rostam | Character Type: Pink Bigfoot, Bat, Blue Tadpole, Peach Badger | VIEW LATEST PRICE | Read Our Analysis |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Olma Strawberry Cat – Official Jazwares Plush
The Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Olma Strawberry Cat stands out as the perfect Valentine’s gift for collectors who value authenticity. This official Jazwares plush features ultrasoft, high-quality Mallow materials that’ll make every squeeze memorable. You’ll recognize its authenticity through the official seal, ensuring you’re getting a genuine Squishmallows product.
Olma’s strawberry cat design brings unique personality traits that resonate with Valentine’s Day themes. When you join the Squad, you’re connecting with a passionate community of collectors. This 8-inch plush belongs to the Original Squishmallows collection, which includes FuzzAMallows, HugMees, Mystery Squad, and Stackables—perfect for expanding your collection.
- Size:8-Inch
- Character Name:Olma
- Character Type:Strawberry Cat
- Material:Ultrasoft, high-quality Mallow materials
- Manufacturer:Official Jazwares
- Unique Bio:Has unique designs and personality traits
- Additional Feature:Strawberry cat design
- Additional Feature:Official authenticity seal
- Additional Feature:Multiple product extensions
Squishmallows 12in Artin Pink Loch Ness Monster
Artin the Pink Loch Ness Monster brings mythical charm to Valentine’s Day with hearts adorning its ultrasoft 12-inch body, making it perfect for anyone who loves whimsical creatures with a romantic twist. This official Jazwares Valentine plush features high-quality material that’s irresistibly huggable. Artin comes with a unique name and bio, plus he’s ready to dress up for any occasion. Look for the official Squishmallows seal to ensure you’re getting an authentic product. You can also explore other extensions like FuzzAMallows, HugMees, Mystery Squad, and Stackables to expand your collection.
- Size:12-Inch
- Character Name:Artin
- Character Type:Pink Loch Ness Monster
- Material:Ultrasoft, high-quality material
- Manufacturer:Official Jazwares
- Unique Bio:Dresses up for any occasion
- Additional Feature:Valentine’s Day themed
- Additional Feature:Hearts design feature
- Additional Feature:Dresses for any occasion
Squishmallows 14in Milan Navy Blue Fruit Bat
Milan the Navy Blue Fruit Bat stands out as an exceptional choice for anyone seeking a Valentine’s gift that celebrates uniqueness and emotional connection. This 14-inch official Jazwares plush features Milan wearing an adorable heart headband, perfectly suited for the romantic holiday. You’ll appreciate the ultrasoft, high-quality material that makes every squeeze irresistible. Milan’s character bio emphasizes empathy, making this Squishmallow meaningful beyond its cuddly exterior. When you’re shopping, look for the official seal to ensure authenticity. This large-sized bat offers excellent huggability while showcasing a distinctive navy blue design that breaks from traditional Valentine’s colors, appealing to those who prefer something refreshingly different.
- Size:14-Inch
- Character Name:Milan
- Character Type:Navy Blue Fruit Bat
- Material:Ultrasoft, high-quality material
- Manufacturer:Official Jazwares
- Unique Bio:Values empathy
- Additional Feature:Heart headband accessory
- Additional Feature:Values empathy trait
- Additional Feature:Large size option
Squishmallows 5in Herb Green Sea Turtle Plush
Sports enthusiasts and baseball fans will adore Herb, the 5-inch green sea turtle Squishmallow who doubles as an adorable Valentine’s gift. This official Jazwares plush features a charming heart design and comes with Herb’s unique bio identifying him as a baseball pitcher. You’ll appreciate the ultrasoft, high-quality material that makes this compact companion perfect for cuddling. Look for the official Squishmallows seal to ensure authenticity. At 5 inches, Herb’s portable size lets your Valentine carry this lovable turtle everywhere while celebrating their passion for America’s favorite pastime.
- Size:5-Inch
- Character Name:Herb
- Character Type:Green Sea Turtle
- Material:Ultrasoft, high-quality material
- Manufacturer:Official Jazwares
- Unique Bio:Baseball pitcher
- Additional Feature:Baseball pitcher character
- Additional Feature:Heart design detail
- Additional Feature:Compact 5-inch size
Squishmallows Valentine’s Day 4-Pack (Amazon Exclusive)
This Amazon-exclusive 4-pack delivers exceptional value for collectors who want multiple Valentine’s-themed characters in one purchase. You’ll receive Patty the Pink Bigfoot, Emily the Bat, Agnolo the Blue Tadpole, and Rostam the Peach Badger, each with unique backstories that add personality to your collection. The ultrasoft fabric makes them perfect for cuddling during flights or cozy nights. At 5 inches tall and weighing just 1.26 pounds total, they’re portable and easy to display. With a 4.9-star rating from 143 reviews, these Valentine’s Squishmallows prove their popularity. They’re recommended for ages 3 and up, making them versatile gifts.
- Size:5-Inch (4-Pack)
- Character Name:Patty, Emily, Agnolo, Rostam
- Character Type:Pink Bigfoot, Bat, Blue Tadpole, Peach Badger
- Material:Ultrasoft, high-quality fabric
- Manufacturer:Jazwares, LLC
- Unique Bio:Patty works at farmers market, Emily studies stars, Agnolo improves public speaking, Rostam is a fencer
- Additional Feature:Amazon exclusive availability
- Additional Feature:Four characters included
- Additional Feature:4.9 star rating
Factors to Consider When Choosing Valentine’s Squishmallows
When shopping for Valentine’s Squishmallows, you’ll want to evaluate several key features to find the perfect plush for your loved one. The right choice depends on factors like size preferences, character appeal, and how much you’re willing to spend. Let’s explore what makes certain Squishmallows stand out from the rest this Valentine’s Day season.
Size and Display Options
Squishmallows arrive in multiple sizes ranging from compact 5-inch versions to substantial 14-inch plushies, giving you flexibility in how you display and enjoy these Valentine’s-themed collectibles. Larger 14-inch options make perfect statement pieces for your bed or sofa, while smaller sizes fit ideally on desktops or travel with you easily.
Consider your intended use when selecting a size. If you’re gifting, think about the recipient’s space and preferences. For cuddling, opt for medium to large sizes. If you’re building a collection, mixing various sizes creates dynamic, visually appealing displays that showcase multiple Valentine’s characters.
Different sizes let you customize arrangements in bedrooms, playrooms, or living spaces, transforming these adorable plushies into charming décor elements that celebrate the season of love.
Character Design and Personality
Beyond their cuddly exteriors, each Valentine’s Squishmallow brings a distinct personality and backstory that transforms these plushies from simple toys into meaningful collectibles. You’ll find characters with unique interests—one might work at a farmers market, while another studies star patterns. These distinctive traits let you choose Squishmallows that reflect your own experiences and passions.
When selecting Valentine’s designs, consider which personalities resonate with you or your gift recipient. The characters’ backstories create emotional connections that make collecting more engaging. You can join the “Squad” community and share favorite characters’ stories with fellow fans. This personalization aspect helps you express individuality while fostering camaraderie with collectors who appreciate similar designs and character traits.
Material Quality and Softness
The moment you touch a Valentine’s Squishmallow, you’ll notice the distinctive ultrasoft ‘Mallow materials’ that set these plushies apart from standard stuffed toys. This high-quality fabric creates an ideal tactile experience for hugging and cuddling, making them perfect companions for cozy Valentine’s Day celebrations.
The premium materials serve dual purposes: they deliver immediate comfort while ensuring long-lasting durability. You won’t need to worry about wear and tear from frequent squeezing. Each Squishmallow’s soft fabric enhances its unique personality and design, adding to its collectible appeal.
When shopping, look for the official seal that confirms authentic Mallow materials. This guarantee ensures you’re getting a product that meets stringent quality standards, so you’ll experience the signature softness that makes Squishmallows beloved worldwide.
Authenticity and Official Seals
When shopping for Valentine’s Squishmallows, you’ll want to verify authenticity before making your purchase. Always look for an official seal that confirms the product’s legitimacy. Authentic Squishmallows feature ultrasoft, high-quality “Mallow materials” that create their distinctive texture and feel.
Products that don’t clearly state they’re “official Squishmallows” may fail to meet brand quality standards and could be counterfeit. You’ll reduce the risk of buying non-authentic products by purchasing from reputable retailers or directly from official brand sources.
Consider joining the Squishmallow community to gain valuable insights on identifying genuine products. Community members share experiences and recommendations that’ll help you distinguish authentic Squishmallows from imitations, ensuring you’re getting the real deal for your Valentine’s Day collection.
Budget and Pack Options
After confirming you’ve found an authentic product, you’ll need to determine which buying option fits your budget best. Individual Squishmallows vary significantly in price based on size—5-inch versions cost less than their 12-inch or 14-inch counterparts.
Consider the Valentine’s Day 4-Pack for maximum value. You’ll get multiple characters in one purchase, saving money compared to buying individual plush toys. This pack option provides an economical way to build your collection while staying within budget.
Watch for seasonal promotions during Valentine’s Day, as retailers often offer special deals or exclusive packs. These limited-time offers can stretch your dollar further.
Before purchasing, verify the age recommendations. Most collections suit children ages 3 and up, ensuring your investment meets safety standards while providing lasting enjoyment.
Conclusion
Whether you’re treating yourself or surprising someone special, these Valentine’s Squishmallows offer something for everyone. You’ll find options ranging from the adorable Olma Strawberry Cat to the exclusive 4-Pack collection. Consider your recipient’s preferences, from size to character design, and don’t forget those heartwarming backstories that make each plush unique. Whichever you choose, you’re guaranteed to deliver comfort and joy this Valentine’s Day 2026. Start squeezing your favorites today!